Long-term Care Facilities and Directors Charged in Fire Evacuation Failure

When wildfire swept through the Santa Rosa, California area in October of 2017, at least two long-term care facilities were grossly unprepared, and their staff made feeble attempts to evacuate almost 300 residents. If residents’ families and others had not stepped in, as many as 20 elderly residents would have died when the buildings burned down.
There are lessons in here for every healthcare provider:
  1. As you work to adhere to the emergency preparedness Conditions of Participation from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), remember that, in the first line, it requires you to “comply with all applicable Federal, State, and local emergency preparedness requirements.” In this case, it was state requirements that were not adhered to, which allowed California’s Department of Social Services to take legal action.
  2. Having an emergency plan is not sufficient. In this case, the plan was left in the binder on a shelf, probably because the night staff (at least) had not been trained how to use it.
  3. Training matters. None of the four nursing staff on duty at one of the facilities had ever received training in building evacuation. As a result, they could not find the keys to the facility’s buses, nor could they find flashlights or batteries.
  4. Exercises matter. None of the four employees at one of the facilities had “participated in a fire drill involving evacuating all residents.”
  5. Leadership matters. In both facilities, administrators failed their residents and staff. One never showed. The other arrived and directed staff “to return the residents to their rooms” because he “did not want to cause issues or make trouble.”

After fumbling around, staff finally loaded a few residents into their own personal vehicles and then drove to a shelter. They did not notify emergency services either before or after their own evacuation. When residents’ family members arrived on the scene, they took matters into their own hands. Family members, working with emergency personnel, completed the evacuation. According to the report, “if these family members and emergency responders had not evacuated Villa Capri residents, more than 20 residents would have perished when Villa Capri burned to the ground after all staff left the facility.”
Just weeks before California’s Department of Social Services filed this complaint, the ownership of Villa Capri settled a civil lawsuit brought on behalf of families of 17 residents, who charged the facility with abandoning their residents during the fire.
Disasters can happen at any time, through no fault of a healthcare provider. If that provider does not have an emergency plan that all staff can follow, the provider is going to be in big trouble, even if no one gets killed. If you are not sure your emergency preparedness program is up to the task, ask us to take a look at it.
Categories: Healthcare | Rick Christ

Find Articles by:

  • We'd Love to Hear Your Comments


    Submit a Comment

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Related Articles: CMS Rules for Healthcare Providers

    Annual Review of Emergency Preparedness Plan

        by Rick Christ Current CMS Emergency Preparedness Conditions of Participation require an annual review of your emergency preparedness plan. Under the proposed rule, the plan “must be evaluated and updated at least every 2 years.” Not in the rule, but in...

    Why We Support More Detailed Exercise Standards

        by Rick Christ Currently, almost every provider type is required to participate in two exercises per year. One “should be” a “community full-scale exercise” while the other can be a tabletop. The original version of the current exercise standards was...

    Do the Proposed Changes to Training Make Sense?

        by Rick Christ Currently, the typical CMS regulation says this about the training requirement: The training and testing program must be reviewed and updated at least annually. (1) Training program. The hospital must do all of the following:(i) Initial...

    What You Need to Know About the Proposed Rule Changes to CMS

        by Rick Christ Barely ten months into the enforcement period of the Emergency Preparedness Conditions of Participation, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) is proposing some rule changes that would “reform Medicare regulations that are...

    Our Newsletter

    Remember, we will NEVER share your email address or SPAM you.
    You may unsubscribe at any time.

    Website design & development by Carbon Six Digital Marketing Agency